安魂曲
[个人文集]
加入时间: 2004/02/14
文章: 12787
经验值: 0
|
|
|
作者：安魂曲 在 罕见奇谈 发贴, 来自 http://www.hjclub.org
（以下是BBC专题留言版中最受读者欢迎的前几个留言，全部留言可以去http://newsforums.bbc.co.uk/nol/thread.jspa?sortBy=2&threadID=904&edition=2&ttl=20060203022841&#paginator那里欣赏，有很多真知灼见。）
Yes they should have been published.
Islamic law does not apply to newspapers published in the West and Muslims cannot expect to be able impose Islamic law on non-Muslims. Muslims need to appreciate that their religion (and therefore Mohammed) is sacred only to themselves. If they have faith then no amount of cartoons in western newspapers should matter.
nicky Molasses, London, United Kingdom
Recommended by 985 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:43 GMT 16:43 UK
Come on BBC - either you are going to conduct a serious debate, including showing the cartoons in question so open-minded people can give an informed opinion, or you're not.
If in order to protect Muslim sensibilities regarding the portrayal of the Prophet Mohammed you feel you have to refrain from publishing the cartoons, there is no debate. You've already decided they shouldn't be published. So why bother asking what I think?
easterhay, Buenos Aires
Recommended by 847 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:35 GMT 16:35 UK
Denmark is not an Islamic country. It has freedom of speech and press. How dare Muslims across the world burn the Danish flag and threaten death upon that nation for such an innocuous publication.
Peter, United Kingdom
Recommended by 798 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:40 GMT 16:40 UK
I am proud to see European press show solidarity with Denmark. Yes, the drawings are offensive to Muslims, just as there is material in European papers that offends Christians on a daily basis. That is what freedom of speech means. To Muslims living in Europe who are offended and demand government action: move to Saudi Arabia, you will not have such problems there. To Muslims in Arab countries who are offended: nobody is forcing European papers on you. If you don't like them, don't read them.
Nathan Wajsman, Amsterdam
Recommended by 775 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:44 GMT 16:44 UK
No, no censorship. It is a complete over reaction from a section that appears to relish the role of being victimised and demonised. If you preach tolerance and expect it - then give it too. Depict Jesus in the same light if you want - you won't see flag burning and embassy closures here for it. We have free speech - and we'll keep it, thanks
Stuart, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Recommended by 670 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:19 GMT 16:19 UK
In Muslim countries, cartoons, newspaper articales and television shows call Jews pigs and apes. They cites things like the forgery, Protocals of the Elders of Zion, they continually publish anti-Jewish...not talking anti-Israel here but anti-Jewish media. Muslims do not have a leg to stand on here.
Matthew, Vienna, VA
Recommended by 645 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:41 GMT 16:41 UK
It is completely beyond me why we should let people from another continent limit our freedom of speech because they don't have any sense of humour.
Theo Braat, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Recommended by 637 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:34 GMT 16:34 UK
Of course they should have been published. What I want to know is, why haven't the BBC or the rest of the British press reproduced the cartoons, so that we can make up our own minds?
Why isn't the BBC raising the banner for free speech? What is the BBC afraid of?
Last week the BBC ran a debate on censorship in China. It looks like we've got censorship a lot closer to home.
[chatmandu_uk], London, United Kingdom
Recommended by 621 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:32 GMT 16:32 UK
This has nothing to do with respect. If it had, then the Islamic governments of the world would respect the rights of Westerners to have secular governments and exercise their inalienable right to free speech. Once again we see the intolerance and oppressive tyranny of religion at work. Everything is open to criticism and ridicule in the West, including Islam, and of course the cartoons should have been published.
[pvandck], Provincia di Treviso, Italy
Recommended by 555 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:44 GMT 16:44 UK
I have one message for the Muslim world. Lighten up!
Dan Damiata
Recommended by 480 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:30 GMT 16:30 UK
By all means possiable. Why have they not been published on BBC? Scared? (which is why you sould post them).
Bill Newland, Rigby ID US
Recommended by 445 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:29 GMT 16:29 UK
Yes they should! The freedoms of speech and religion enshrined in western law were, in many cases, paid for in blood.
Let's not forget that these are the same people that would burn your flag in your face, and not care if you were offended.
Juan, Queens, NY, USA
Recommended by 429 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:33 GMT 16:33 UK
If muslims are looking for respect and feel as though their pride has been wounded, they should still be willing to respect others. In this case the freedom of speech in western lands. I don't think they would hesitate to burn bibles, call westerners infidels, and issue fatwas to kill people for speaking their mind, not to mention disavowing the history and culture of others - at the same time their hand is out for respect. It's a system which is doomed to never play well with other systems.
richard S, Los Angeles
Recommended by 428 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 20:27 GMT 20:27 UK
While we regret having caused offense . . . well, wait a minute. Challenges to authority through satire, caricature, and political cartoon are our best non-violent release valves. The right to offend becomes a civic duty when religion & politics threaten. We need more such cartoons.
T.Schield Williams, New York, NY
Recommended by 417 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
Added: Wednesday, 1 February, 2006, 16:44 GMT 16:44 UK
Offence and bad taste are all part of being in the public arena. What I find truly insulting is when a cleric calls for attacks on me or my neighbors and isn't immediately condemened by the faithful.
Bruce Rerek, Brooklyn, United States
Recommended by 416 people
Sign in to recommend comments.
Complain about this comment.
作者：安魂曲 在 罕见奇谈 发贴, 来自 http://www.hjclub.org |
|
|
建议大家去看看BBC的网上留言板：大多数人都反感穆斯林的过分反应------
