海纳百川

登录 | 登录并检查站内短信 | 个人设置 网站首页 |  论坛首页 |  博客 |  搜索 |  收藏夹 |  帮助 |  团队  | 注册  | RSS
主题: 票友犯了一个错误,看过票友“奸坛可能确实没有数学高手”的网友请进
回复主题   printer-friendly view    海纳百川首页 -> 驴鸣镇
阅读上一个主题 :: 阅读下一个主题  
作者 票友犯了一个错误,看过票友“奸坛可能确实没有数学高手”的网友请进   
所跟贴 票友犯了一个错误,看过票友“奸坛可能确实没有数学高手”的网友请进 -- 一票友 - (945 Byte) 2010-6-20 周日, 上午10:15 (362 reads)
Thinker




性别: 性别:男

加入时间: 2009/08/16
文章: 20

经验值: 1120


文章标题: The problem of your proof (111 reads)      时间: 2010-6-22 周二, 上午10:35

作者:Thinker驴鸣镇 发贴, 来自 http://www.hjclub.org

Dear Mr. Piao You,

There are two problems with your proof:

1. You did not point out where goes wrong with the original proof. What you did at most was to show there was another line of logic leading to a different conclusion. In other words, what you did at most was to show a paradox, rather than a disproof of the original proof.

2. Your own proof suffers from a potential flaw: since the sum of widths of mulitple points can still be zero, zero width cannot imply it belongs to one single point. Thus, the limit of zero width for the line when N approaches infinity cannot ensure that it is correponding to one point. As a result, your proof does not prove anything.

Regardless of this, I personally very much admire your intelligence, creativity and ambition. Your work, in my perspective, may lead to a new mathematic theory, although there is still some work to be done until then.

作者:Thinker驴鸣镇 发贴, 来自 http://www.hjclub.org
返回顶端
阅读会员资料 Thinker离线  发送站内短信 发送电子邮件
    显示文章:     
    回复主题   printer-friendly view    海纳百川首页 -> 驴鸣镇 所有的时间均为 北京时间


     
    论坛转跳:   
    不能在本论坛发表新主题
    不能在本论坛回复主题
    不能在本论坛编辑自己的文章
    不能在本论坛删除自己的文章
    不能在本论坛发表投票
    不能在这个论坛添加附件
    可以在这个论坛下载文件


    based on phpbb, All rights reserved.
    [ Page generation time: 0.04417 seconds ] :: [ 24 queries excuted ] :: [ GZIP compression enabled ]